SunnyNestHOMES

A Sibling Is Living in Mom's House and Won't Leave or Sell: Your Options, in Order

By Ed Brancheau, Co-founder, SunnyNest Homes. Reviewed by the SunnyNest family team. Updated November 2026.

Can I sell an inherited house if my sibling lives in it?

Usually not without every owner's signature or a court order. In California the usual order is: find out who holds title, agree on a value, offer a buyout, try mediation and only then file a partition action, where a judge can order the house sold.

This page is one part of our main guide to selling an inherited house. It walks through California's rules in the order a family should try them.

Fighting your own brother or sister over Mom's house, while you are still grieving her, is one of the hardest things a family goes through. You do not have to solve it this week. You can start it this week.

Your first three moves:

  1. Pull the deed.Find out whose names are on it and whether probate is open. If only Mom's name is on it, probate (or her trust) comes first.
  2. Start a log. Who pays the property tax, insurance and repairs, and who lives there. Keep every receipt. If the property tax is behind, that comes first, because unpaid tax can end in a tax sale (Revenue and Taxation Code 3691).
  3. Book one hour with a probate or real estate attorney. Bring the deed and the log. Ask the price of that first meeting when you call. If you do not know who to call, ask your county bar association for a lawyer referral.

The rest of this page explains each option, in order, so you know what that attorney will talk about.

“6 siblings inherited a house. One sibling will not move out of the house so we can sell it. Any legal rights?”

Someone in Jacksonville, Florida asked that question on Avvo, a lawyer question and answer site, in February 2014 (source). One of the Florida probate attorneys who answered, Hollyn June Foster, put the hard part in one line: “Since the sibling holds an ownership interest in the home, eviction is not an option.” California has its own rules for this fight, and every code section below links to the official text so you can read it yourself.

Who owns the house right now?

It depends on where the estate is. If it sits in a living trust, the trust's attorney can tell you who controls it.

Pull the deed first. Ask the estate's attorney, or look up the recorded deed with your county recorder. Three situations look the same at the kitchen table and are completely different in court:

Probate is open

Who controls it:
The executor (the court calls this person the personal representative)
What that means for a sibling living there:
The executor can ask the sibling to hand over the house (Probate Code 9650)

In a living trust

Who controls it:
The successor trustee
What that means for a sibling living there:
The trust's terms and the trustee's duties control. Ask the trust's attorney

If you have not started probate yet, our guide to selling a house without probate in California covers the shortcuts, including a simpler court petition for a parent's home worth up to 750,000 dollars (Probate Code 13151).

Can the executor make a sibling move out during probate?

Often, yes. California Probate Code 9650 gives the executor the right to take possession of estate property. It lets an heir stay in the house until the executor decides possession is needed to run the estate. Then the law says the person holding the property shall surrender it on request.

What if the sibling still says no?Then ask the executor's attorney about taking it to the probate court that is already overseeing the estate. What they file depends on the case, so this is the hour with an attorney that matters most. Bring the written request and the date it was made.

This is the step most families miss, because they skip straight to arguing about partition. Until the house is distributed, the executor has a job to do: pay the taxes and protect the property, which is also in section 9650 (Probate Code 9650).

What if the sibling living there is also the executor?

This is common, and it is harder, because the person who should ask for the house back is the person living in it. The other heirs still have options inside the probate case:

  1. Ask in writing first. Ask the executor to put the plan for the house in writing: sell, buy out the others or rent at a fair price.
  2. Ask the probate court to step in.California law lets the court remove an executor who has “wasted, embezzled, mismanaged” the estate, “wrongfully neglected” it, or when removal is “necessary for protection of the estate or interested persons” (Probate Code 8502). Living there for free while the taxes go unpaid is the kind of fact a court weighs.
  3. Bring your records. The who-paid-what log below is what your attorney shows the judge.

A probate attorney files this, and it is worth paying one for an hour before you decide.

Can you evict a sibling who co-owns the house?

Do not try to evict a co-owner. California's tool is a formal written demand for shared possession under Civil Code 843. If the sibling does not offer it within 60 days, the law treats them as having shut you out, and you can claim money for it.

In short (Civil Code 843): you formally deliver a written demand to share the house, the way court papers are delivered, and an attorney can handle that. If 60 days pass and your sibling does not offer to share it, the law treats that as shutting you out, and you can claim money for it, on its own or inside a partition case.

The same section says the owners can agree at any time on who lives there and on paying a reasonable rent instead. That agreement is usually the cheapest outcome on this whole page.

Does a sibling living in the inherited house owe rent?

Not automatically. Under Civil Code 843 the owners can agree in writing on a reasonable rent. In a partition case, a California judge can order an accounting and other fair adjustments among the owners. That is where years of free use, unpaid property taxes and repairs get weighed against each other.

The accounting power is one sentence in the partition law: the court “may, in all cases, order allowance, accounting, contribution, or other compensatory adjustment among the parties according to the principles of equity” (Code of Civil Procedure 872.140).

So keep records from day one. Who paid the property tax, the insurance, the roof repair. Who lived there and when. A judge weighing fairness can only weigh what someone can show.

How does a sibling buyout work, and what price is fair?

The fair price for each share is the appraised value of the whole house times that heir's share. California's partition law uses exactly that formula. Three siblings with equal shares in an 800,000 dollar house means each share is worth about 266,667 dollars, before any credits for taxes or repairs.

That formula comes from Code of Civil Procedure 874.317, which sets the buyout price inside a partition case. Families can use the same math without ever going to court.

A worked example.Mom's house appraises at 800,000 dollars. Three siblings each own one third. Dana lives there and wants to keep it.

Appraised value of the whole house

Amount:
800,000 dollars

Each one-third share

Amount:
about 266,667 dollars

Dana buys out her brother and sister

Amount:
about 533,333 dollars total

Credit if Dana paid the property tax alone for the 3 years since Mom died (example: 9,000 dollars a year, two thirds of it was theirs)

Amount:
Dana pays about 18,000 dollars less

The hard part is rarely the math. It is whether the sibling in the house can get a loan for half a million dollars. Ask early and kindly whether they can get a lender to prequalify them, because a buyout that cannot be funded is just a longer argument.

A buyout can go either way. If you are the one who wants the house, you can buy out the sibling living there with the same math.

What if nobody can afford a buyout? Then the honest ending for most families is to sell the house and split the money by share, after the credits.

Two things make a buyout go smoother:

  • One appraisal everyone trusts. Agree on a licensed appraiser before anyone sees a number.
  • The credits in writing. List who paid what, and agree on it before the appraisal comes back.

What if nobody can agree?

Try mediation before court. A trained mediator meets with every heir, keeps the talk on numbers and writes up what the family agrees to. A signed agreement can cover the buyout, a move-out date or a sale, and it stays private.

This is also where a written number from outside the family helps. An appraisal, a Realtor's market analysis or a written as-is offer turns “Mom would never want this” into a figure everyone can look at. Your attorney can usually recommend a mediator who handles family property cases.

What is a partition action in California?

In California any co-owner can file one. The Partition of Real Property Act applies to partition cases filed on or after January 1, 2023 (Code of Civil Procedure 874.311).

Any co-owner of real property can start one (Code of Civil Procedure 872.210). For co-owners who share the house at the same time, which is how heirs usually hold it, the law says partition “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver” (872.710).

Check the deed for the words “tenants in common.” For those houses, a newer California law sets the order, in cases filed since January 1, 2023. In plain words: the court gets an appraisal. If one owner asked for a sale, the others get 45 days to say they will buy that owner out at the appraised price. If nobody buys, the court splits the property itself unless splitting it would badly hurt the owners as a group, and if it would, the court orders a sale (874.318). In that sale, a licensed broker offers the house on the open market at a price no lower than the court's value (874.320).

When it decides whether to split or sell, the court must weigh the family's history with the house, how an owner uses it and who paid the taxes and upkeep (874.319). If you live far away and paid the tax bills, your receipts count too. (The law: 874.311 to 874.320.)

One warning. Partition is a tool for ending a deadlock.

Can you stop a partition action?

Rarely. California law says partition between co-owners is a right unless a valid waiver bars it, such as a signed agreement not to partition. What the sibling in the house usually can do is buy the others out at the appraised value, ask for credits for taxes and repairs, and ask the court to weigh the family's history.

That right is in Code of Civil Procedure 872.710. So a sibling who wants to keep the house is usually better off starting the buyout talk early than fighting the case. If you are served with partition papers, do not ignore them. The summons tells you how many days you have to respond (Code of Civil Procedure 412.20). Take the papers to a real estate attorney that week.

How long does a partition action take?

Months at the least. Even when a sibling buys out the others, the waiting periods written into California's partition law add up to at least 135 days, counted from the day the court mails notice of the appraisal. Filing and serving the lawsuit, the appraisal itself, court calendars and any sale all come on top.

The hearing on value comes at least 30 days after the court sends notice of the appraisal (874.316). After the court's notice of value, an owner gets 45 days to say they will buy, and buyers get at least 60 more days to pay (874.317). The court sets the real dates, so treat 135 days as the floor, not a forecast.

Who pays for a partition action, and how much does it cost?

Usually everyone, by share. California law lets the court count reasonable attorney's fees spent for the shared good, the fees of a referee (a neutral person the court can appoint to handle the sale) and title reports as costs of partition. Then it splits those costs among the owners by their shares, or another way that is fair.

Those rules are in Code of Civil Procedure 874.010 and 874.040. In plain terms, the sibling who files does not pay alone, and the sibling who fought it does not get off free.

What does a case cost in dollars? We could not find a reliable public figure for a California partition case, and we will not invent one. Ask every attorney you interview for a written estimate, and ask how much of it depends on whether the other side fights.

What happens to the sibling living there if the house is sold?

Their share of the money goes with them, and the house goes to the buyer. A court-ordered sale happens on the terms and conditions the court sets, so the move-out date and how the house gets shown belong in that order. A sale the family agrees to can put the move-out money right in the contract.

Under section 874.320, the court's broker sells “on the terms and conditions established by the court.” Ask your attorney to put access for showings and a move-out date in those terms.

Should we list it with a Realtor or sell it as-is?

If the family agrees and the house can be shown, list it with a Realtor. That usually nets the most, often a lot more, and a real estate attorney should review the contract. A direct sale makes sense when the house cannot be emptied or shown, or when the repairs and the fight would cost more than the price gap.

Please do not sell it yourselves to save the commission. With several heirs, a deadline and a sibling in the house, one mistake in the price, the disclosures or the contract can cost more than the commission saves. Here is the longer version of why we say that.

Is SunnyNest the right call for your family?

Usually not. SunnyNest Homes is a small family business that buys houses (who we are), and we fit about 1 in 20 sellers. Most families in this spot should list once they agree.

List with a Realtor if the family agrees to sell, the house can be emptied and shown, and you have a few months.

Work out a buyout if the sibling in the house wants to keep it and can get a loan.

Talk to an attorney about partition if someone will not sign anything and talks have stopped.

A written cash offer may fit ifthe family agrees to sell and nobody can get the house empty or shown. We can buy it with your brother or sister still living there, with the move-out money written into the contract. Every owner still signs, or a court order does. So if your brother or sister will not sign anything, we cannot help yet, and the steps above (an executor's request, the probate court or partition) come first.

We show every heir the same numbers at the same time: a ballpark first, then one written offer, with the math behind it. The written offer also shows what a Realtor listing would likely net for that house, in dollars, so the family can see the trade-off before anyone signs.

What should I do first?

Find out who holds title today. Then write down who paid what since the death, get one shared value and talk to a probate or real estate attorney before anyone files anything. Start with paper, not arguments.

  1. Pull the deed and find out whether probate is open, the house is in a trust or it was distributed.
  2. Start a simple log: property tax, insurance, repairs, utilities, who lived there and when.
  3. Get one appraisal everyone agrees to in advance.
  4. Ask the sibling in the house, in writing, whether they want to buy, rent or sell.
  5. Call a probate or real estate attorney. Bring the deed, the log and the appraisal.
  6. Try mediation before court.
  7. Only then, if the family is stuck, ask the attorney about partition.

Our honest offer

Whatever your family decides, we will send a free written side-by-side, in dollars, for your house: what you would likely net by listing with a Realtor, and what you would net selling to SunnyNest Homes. Every heir sees the same page. If listing wins, we will say so.

Will our number drop later? Not for anything you told us or showed us. A problem nobody knew about comes out of our fee first. Past a limit written in your contract, the price moves only by the extra, you see the contractor's bid line by line, and you can cancel for free. (The full answer is here.)

Questions sellers ask us

My sister is living rent free in the inherited house. What can I do?

If probate is still open, the executor can ask her to hand over the house under Probate Code 9650. If the house is already distributed, she is a co-owner, so the tools are a written rent agreement, a formal demand under Civil Code 843 or an accounting inside a partition case under Code of Civil Procedure 872.140.

Can one sibling stop the sale of an inherited house?

Not forever. Any co-owner can file a partition action, and California law makes partition between co-owners a right unless a valid waiver bars it. Under the Partition of Real Property Act, any owner who did not ask for a sale can buy out the owners who did, at the value the court sets.

How do you beat a partition action?

Usually you get ahead of it instead. Partition between co-owners is a right in California unless a valid waiver bars it. The sibling who wants the house can offer to buy at the appraised value and ask for credits for taxes and repairs.

What happens if a sibling ignores a partition lawsuit?

The case does not stop because one owner stays silent. The summons says how many days the owner has to respond. Anyone served should take the papers to a real estate attorney before that deadline passes.

How much does a partition action cost?

We could not find a reliable public dollar figure for California, so ask attorneys for a written estimate. The court can split shared attorney's fees and other costs of partition among the owners by share.

What is a partition sale?

The sale a court orders when a co-owned house cannot be fairly split. In California a licensed broker offers it on the open market at no less than the court's value. Each owner gets their share of the money after costs and credits.

Does this work the same way in Arizona or Texas?

Not necessarily. This page covers California only. The Florida question at the top of this page is a good example: the attorneys there answered under Florida law. Ask an attorney licensed in the state where the house is.

What if the property taxes are not being paid?

That is urgent, because in California the county can sell a home five years after its property tax goes into default (Revenue and Taxation Code 3691). Pay it to protect the house, keep the receipts and ask for the credit in the buyout or the partition accounting.

Get numbers every heir can see: a free written side-by-side, in dollars, listing with a Realtor versus selling to us. If listing wins, we'll say so.

Tell us about the property. Ed gets back to you within one business day to set up a short call, and on it he walks you through a ballpark for every way we could buy it, in writing, in dollars. If we are close, a 20-minute video walkthrough firms it up before any offer. No pressure, no obligation, and we will tell you if listing with a Realtor is your better move.

Comes with a couple of other options, side by side.

The sources behind this page

  • “6 siblings inherited a house. One sibling will not move out of the house so we can sell it. Any legal rights?” and the answer by Hollyn June Foster, probate attorney (Avvo, Jacksonville, Florida, February 20, 2014)
  • Executor possession, and the heir shall surrender it on request (California Probate Code 9650)
  • Removing an executor who wasted, mismanaged or neglected the estate (California Probate Code 8502)
  • The written demand for shared possession, the 60 days and the rent agreement (California Civil Code 843)
  • The accounting, who may file, and partition as of right (Code of Civil Procedure 872.140, 872.210, 872.710)
  • The Partition of Real Property Act: appraisal, the 45-day buyout window, the buyout price, the factors and the open-market sale by a broker (Code of Civil Procedure 874.311 to 874.320)
  • Added by the fact check on November 17, 2026: the personal representative, the 750,000 dollar petition, the summons, split or sell, the factors, and the tax sale (Probate Code 58 and 13151, Code of Civil Procedure 412.20, 874.318 and 874.319, Revenue and Taxation Code 3691)
  • Costs of partition, including attorney's fees, referee fees and title reports, split by share (Code of Civil Procedure 874.010 and 874.040)
  • The worked buyout example (SunnyNest Homes, November 2026. Made-up numbers to show the math)

All checked November 17, 2026.

CallGet Your Cash Offer